The safe-conduct, and the remaining conditions have two narrations: one of them is that the covenant is nullified by them, whether it was stipulated upon them or not. The school of al-Shafi'i is close to this, except that what was not stipulated upon them does not nullify the covenant if abandoned, with the exception of the first three points, for their stipulation is definite, and the covenant is nullified by their abandonment in any case. Abu Hanifa said: The covenant is not nullified except by refusal from the Imam in a manner that makes it impossible to collect the jizya from them. Our proof, along with what we have mentioned, is what was narrated that a man was brought to Umar who had attempted to force a Muslim woman [into zina], and he said: 'We did not make peace with you upon this,' and he ordered that he be crucified in Jerusalem. Furthermore, it involves harm to the Muslims, so it resembles the refusal to pay the jizya. In every instance where we stated that his covenant is not nullified, if he commits an act for which there is a hadd penalty, that hadd or qisas (retaliation) shall be carried out upon him. If it does not warrant a hadd, he shall be given a discretionary punishment (ta'zir), and he shall be dealt with in a manner that deters others from doing the same. If one of them intends to do such an act, he shall be restrained from it, and if he resists with fighting, his covenant is nullified. Whoever among them we have judged to have nullified his covenant, the Imam is given a choice regarding him among [four things]: killing, enslavement, ransom, or release, like a prisoner of war, for he is a disbeliever whom we have overpowered in our land without a covenant or contract, and without any ambiguity, so he resembles a combatant thief. This is specific to him and does not extend to his offspring, because the violation originated from him, not them, just as if he had committed an act warranting a hadd or ta'zir.
Section: The garrison cities (amsar) of the Muslims are of three types. One of them is what the Muslims founded, such as Basra, Kufa, Baghdad, and Wasit. It is not permissible in them to establish a church, a synagogue, or a gathering place for their prayer, nor...
(11) In A, B, and M: "ahaduhuma" (one of them). (12) In B and M: "yashtaritu" (to stipulate). (13) In M: "wa-zahir madhhab" (and the manifest school). (14) In A and M: "yashtarit" (to stipulate). (15) In M: "thalath" (three). (16) In M: there is an addition: "la" (not). (17) Omitted from: the original. (18) Extracted by Abd al-Razzaq, in: The Chapter on the Covenant-Holder who acts treacherously against the Muslim, from the Book of the People of the Two Scriptures. Al-Musannaf 10/363, 364. And Ibn Abi Shaybah, in: The Chapter on the Dhimmi who forces a Muslim woman upon herself, from the Book of Limits. Al-Musannaf 96/10, 97. (19) Omitted from: the original, A, and B.
الأمانِ، وسائرُ الخِصال فيها رِوايتان؛ إحْدَاهما (١١)، أَنَّ العَهْدَ ينتَقِضُ بها، سواءٌ شُرِطَ عليهم ذلك أو لم يُشْرَطْ (١٢). ومذهَبُ (١٣) الشافِعِىِّ قريبٌ من هذا. إلَّا أنَّ ما لَمْ يُشْرَطْ (١٤) عليهم، لا يَنْتَقِضُ العَهْدُ بتَرْكِه، ما خلا الخِصال الثَّلاثِ (١٥) الأُولَى، فإنَّه يَتَعَيَّنُ شرطُها، ويَنْتَقِضُ العَهْدُ بتَرْكِها بكلِّ حالٍ. وقال أبو حنيفة: لا يَنْتَقِضُ العهدُ إلَّا بالامْتِناعِ من الإِمامِ على وجْهٍ (١٦) يتَعذرُ معه أخذُ الجِزْيَه منهم. ولَنا، مع ما ذكرْناه، ما رُوِى أَنَّ عمرَ رُفِعَ إليه رجلٌ قد أرادَ اسْتِكْراهَ امرأةٍ مسلِمَةٍ [على الزِّنَى] (١٧)، فقال: ما عَلَى هذا صالَحْناكُم. وأمرَ به فصُلِبَ فى بيتِ المقْدِسِ (١٨). ولأنَّ فيه ضَررًا على المسلمين، فأشْبَهَ الامْتناعَ من بَذْلِ الجِزْيَةِ. كلُّ موضع قُلْنا: لا ينْتَقِضُ عهدُه. فإنَّه إنْ فعلَ ما فيه حَدٌّ أُقيمَ عليه حَدُّه أو قِصاصُه، وإن لم يوجبْ حدًّا، عُزِّرَ، ويُفْعَلُ به ما ينْكَفُّ به أمثالُه عن فِعْلِه. فإنْ أرادَ أحدٌ منهم فِعْلَ ذلك كُفَّ عنه، فإنْ مانَعَ بالقتالِ نُقِضَ عهدُه. ومَنْ حَكَمْنا بنَقْضِ عَهْدِه منهم، خُير الإِمامُ فيه بينَ [أربعةِ أشياءَ] (١٩)؛ القتلُ، والاسْتِرْقاقُ، والفِداءُ، والمَنُّ، كالأسيرِ الْحَرْبِىِّ؛ لأنَّه كافِرٌ قَدَرْنا عليه فى دارِنا بغيرِ عَهْدٍ ولا عَقْدٍ، ولا شُبْهَةِ ذلك، فأشْبَهَ اللِّصَّ الْحَرْبِىَّ. ويخْتَصُّ ذلك به دونَ ذُرِّيَتِه؛ لأنَّ النَّقْضَ إنَّما وُجِدَ منه دُونَهم، فاخْتَصَّ به، كما لو أَتَى ما يُوجِبُ حَدًّا أو تَعْزِيرًا.
فصل: أمصارُ المسلمين على ثلاثةِ أقسامٍ، أحدُها، ما مَصَّرَه المسلمون، كالبَصْرَةِ والكوفَةِ وبغدادَ ووَاسِطَ، فلا يجوزُ فيه إحْداثُ كنيسةٍ ولا بِيعَةٍ ولا مُجْتَمَعٍ لصلاتِهم، ولا
(١١) فى أ، ب، م: "أحدهما".(١٢) فى ب، م: "يشترطوا".(١٣) فى م: "وظاهر مذهب".(١٤) فى أ، م: "يشترط".(١٥) فى م: "ثلاث".(١٦) فى م زيادة: "لا".(١٧) سقط من: الأصل.(١٨) أخرجه عبد الرزاق، فى: باب المعاهد يغدر بالمسلم، من كتاب أهل الكتابين. المصنف ١٠/ ٣٦٣، ٣٦٤. وابن أبى شيبة، فى: باب فى الذمى يستكره المسلمة على نفسها، من كتاب الحدود. المصنف ٩٦/ ١٠، ٩٧.(١٩) سقط من: الأصل، أ، ب.