for people, it is disliked, because it adds to their calamity, causes them more work on top of their current state, and is a resemblance (4) to the practice (5) of the people of the Age of Ignorance (Jahiliyyah). It is narrated that Jarir visited Umar and he asked: "Is there wailing over your deceased?" He said: "No." He asked: "Do they gather at the house of the deceased and provide food?" He said: "Yes." He said: "That is wailing (6)." However, if a necessity calls for it, it is permissible; for it may be that those who come to attend the funeral of their deceased come from distant villages and places and spend the night with them, and it is not (7) possible for them [not] (8) to host them.
388 - Issue: He said: (And if a woman dies while she has a child in her womb that moves, her abdomen should not be incised; rather, the midwives should reach in and extract it.)
The meaning of "the midwives reach in" is that they insert their hands into her private part and extract the child from its exit. The school of thought (Madhhab) is that the abdomen of a deceased woman should not be incised to extract her child, whether she was a Muslim or a Dhimmi (a non-Muslim subject under Islamic rule). The midwives should extract it if its life is known by its movement (1). If there are no women present, men should not reach in (2) for it, and the mother should be left until her death is certain, then she is buried. The school of Malik and Ishaq is close to this. It is possible that the mother's abdomen could be incised if it is highly probable that the fetus will live; this is the school of al-Shafi'i (3), because it is the destruction of a part of the deceased to preserve a living being, so it is permissible, just as if part of it had emerged alive and it was not possible for the rest to emerge except by incision. Moreover, because it is incised to extract money from within, then it is more appropriate to do so for the sake of preserving a living person.
(4) In the original: "wa-tashbihan". (5) In A and M: "bi-san'". (6) Mentioned by Shaykh Ahmad Abd al-Rahman al-Banna in Bulugh al-Amani 8/95, and attributed to Sa'id ibn Mansur in his Sunan. (7) In A and M: "wa-la". (8) In M: "illa an". (1) In A and M: "bi-harakah". (2) In the manuscripts: "yastuw". (3) In the marginal notes of M: "The school of al-Shafi'i regarding this issue is more evident. The authority for prioritizing the life of the fetus or the lack thereof is the statement of reliable physicians; rather, it has been proven in practice, so it is not an imaginary matter as the author claimed, based on incomplete experience."
لِلنَّاسِ، فمَكْرُوهٌ؛ لأنَّ فيه زِيَادَةً على مُصِيبتِهم، وشُغْلًا لهم إلى شُغْلِهم، وتَشَبُّهًا (٤) بصَنِيعِ (٥) أهْلِ الجَاهِلِيَّةِ. ورُويَ أنَّ جَرِيرًا وَفَدَ على عمرَ، فقال: هل يُنَاحُ على مَيِّتِكُم؟ قال: لا. قال: فهل يَجْتَمِعُونَ عندَ أهْلِ المَيِّتِ، ويَجْعَلُونَ الطَّعَامَ؟ قال: نعم. قال: ذاكَ النَّوْحُ (٦). وإن دَعَتِ الحاجةُ إلى ذلك جازَ؛ فإنَّه رُبَّما جاءَهم مَن يَحْضُرُ مَيِّتَهم مِن القُرَى والأماكِن البَعِيدَةِ، ويَبِيتُ عِنْدَهم، فلا (٧) يُمْكِنُهم [أنْ لا] (٨) يُضَيِّفُوهُ.
٣٨٨ - مسألة؛ قال: (والْمَرْأَةُ إذَا مَاتَتْ، وفِي بَطْنِها وَلَدٌ يَتَحَرَّكُ، فَلَا يُشَقُّ بَطْنُها، ويَسْطُو عَلَيْهِ الْقَوَابِلُ، فَيُخْرِجْنَهُ)
معنى "يَسْطُو القَوَابِلُ" أن يُدْخِلْنَ أَيْديَهُنَّ في فَرْجِها، فيُخْرِجْنَ الوَلَدَ من مَخْرَجِه. والمذهبُ أنَّه لا يُشَقُّ بَطْنُ المَيِّتَةِ لإِخْراجِ وَلَدِها، مُسْلِمَةً كانت أو ذِمِّيَّةً، وتُخْرِجُه القَوَابِلُ إن عُلِمَتْ حَيَاتُه بحركتِه (١). وإن لم يُوجَدْ نِساءٌ لم يَسْطُ (٢) الرِّجالُ عليه، وتُتْرَكُ أُمُّهُ حتى يُتَيَقَّنَ مَوْتُه، ثم تُدْفَنُ. ومذهبُ مالكٍ، وإسْحاقَ قَرِيبٌ مِن هذا. ويَحْتَمِلُ أن يُشَقَّ بَطْنُ الأُمِّ، إن غَلَب على الظَّنِّ أنَّ الجَنِينَ يَحْيَا، وهو مذهبُ الشَّافِعِىِّ (٣)؛ لأنَّه إتْلَافُ جُزْءٍ من المَيِّتِ لإِبْقَاءِ حَيٍّ، فجَازَ، كما لو خَرَجَ بعضُه حَيًّا، ولم يُمْكِنْ خُرُوجُ بَقِيَّتِه إلَّا بِشَقٍّ، ولأنَّه يُشَقُّ لإِخْراجِ المالِ منه،
(٤) في الأصل: "وتشبيها".(٥) في أ، م: "بصنع".(٦) ذكره الشيخ أحمد عبد الرحمن البنا في بلوغ الأمانى ٨/ ٩٥. وعزاه لسعيد بن منصور في سننه.(٧) في أ، م: "ولا".(٨) في م: "إلا أن".(١) في أ، م: "بحركة".(٢) في النسخ: "يسطو".(٣) في حاشية م: "مذهب الشافعي في المسألة أظهر. والعمدة في ترجيح حياة الجنين وعدمها قول ثقات الأطباء، بل ثبت بالفعل، فليس أمرا موهوما كما قال المصنف، بناء على تجربة ناقصة".