recalled it?" He said: "Yes." I said: "Then how did I do correctly?" He said: "All of that (26) is permissible."
Chapter: And the saying of al-Khiraqi: "And whoever recalls a prayer while he is in another," indicates that whenever he prays while having forgotten the missed prayer [and does not recall it until he finishes, his prayer is valid; he does not have to repeat it] (27). Ahmad explicitly stated this in the narration of the group. He said: Whenever he recalls the missed prayer having already performed the salutation (taslim), it suffices him, and he performs the missed prayer. Malik said: Ordering is mandatory even with forgetfulness. [And the hadith of Abu Jum'ah indicates this, as well as the analogy to the two combined prayers, and because it is an order required when remembering, so it does not lapse due to forgetfulness, like the ordering of purification, and like bowing and prostration] (28). Our evidence is the generality of his saying - peace be upon him -: "My nation is forgiven for mistakes and forgetfulness (29)." And because there is no signifier for the forgotten one, it is permissible for forgetfulness to have an effect on it, like fasting. As for the hadith of Abu Jum'ah, it is from the narration of Ibn Lahi'ah, and there is weakness in it; and it is possible that the Prophet - peace be upon him - recalled it while he was in the prayer. As for the two combined prayers, [one is not excused for forgetfulness regarding them; for forgetfulness does not occur, because the intention to combine them is necessary, so that is not possible while forgetting one of them, and because the presence of the group prevents forgetfulness, as the whole group would hardly forget the first one] (30). There is no difference between him having previously recalled the missed prayer or not having any prior recollection of it, as Ahmad explicitly stated; due to the generality of the evidence we mentioned, and Allah knows best.
201 - Issue; He said: ([If he fears the loss of] (1) the time, he intends while in it that he will not repeat it, and it has sufficed him, [and he performs the one that is upon him] (2)).
Meaning: If he fears the loss of the time before performing the missed prayer and repeating the one he is in, the ordering drops from him at that moment, and he completes his prayer and only performs the missed prayer.
(26) Omitted from: MS (m). (27) In MS (m): "that his prayer is valid". (28) In MS (m): "by the hadith of Abu Jum'ah and by analogy to the two combined prayers". (29) Previously mentioned on page 146 of the first volume. (30) In MS (m): "standing, he is not excused for forgetfulness; for there is a signifier for them, which is the presence of the congregation, unlike our case". (1) In MS (m): "And whoever fears the expiration". (2) Omitted from: MS (m).
ذكَرْتُها؟ قال: بَلَى. قُلْتُ: فكيفَ أَصَبْتُ؟ قالَ: كُلُّ ذلك (٢٦) جائزٌ.
فصل: وقولُ الخِرَقِىِّ: "ومن ذكَرَ صلاةً وَهُوَ في أخْرَى" يَدُلُّ على أنَّه متى صَلَّى ناسِيًا للْفَائِتَةِ [ولم يذْكُرْها حتى فَرَغَ، فصلاته صحيحةٌ، ليس عليه إعادَتُها] (٢٧). وقد نَصَّ أحمدُ على هذا في رِوَايَةِ الجماعةِ، قال: متى ذَكَرَ الفائِتَةَ وقد سَلَّمَ، أجْزأتْه، ويقْضِى الفائتَةَ. وقال مالِكٌ: يَجِبُ التَّرْتِيبُ مع النِّسْيَانِ. [وحديثُ أبي جُمُعةَ يدُلُّ عليه، وكذلك القياسُ على المَجْموعتَيْنِ، ولأنَّه ترتيبٌ يُشْتَرَطُ مع الذِّكْرِ، فلم يسْقُطْ بالنِّسْيانِ، كترتيبِ الطهارة، كالرُّكوعِ والسُّجودِ] (٢٨). ولَنا، عُمُومُ قولِهِ -صلى اللَّه عليه وسلم-: "عُفِىَ لِأُمَّتِى عَنِ الخَطَإِ وَالنِّسْيَانِ (٢٩) ". ولأنَّ المَنْسِيَّةَ ليس عليها أمارَةٌ، فجَازَ أنْ يُؤَثِّرَ فيها النِّسْيانُ، كالصِّيامِ. وأمَّا حديثُ أبى جمعة، فإنَّهُ مِن رِوَايَةِ ابنِ لَهِيعةَ، وفيه ضَعْفٌ ويَحْتَمِلُ أنَّ النَّبِيَّ -صلى اللَّه عليه وسلم- ذكَرَهَا وهو في الصَّلاةِ. وأما المَجْمُوعَتَانِ [فلا يُعْذَرُ بالنِّسْيانِ فيهما؛ فإنَّ النِّسْيانَ لا يتحقَّقُ، لأنَّه لا بُدَّ مِن نِيَّةِ الجَمْعِ بينهما، فلا يُمْكِنُ ذلك مع نِسْيانِ أحدِهما، ولأنَّ اجْتماعَ الجماعةِ يمْنَعُ النِّسْيانَ، إذْ لا يكادُ الجماعةُ كلُّهم ينْسُونَ الأُولَى] (٣٠)، ولا فَرْقَ بين أَنْ يكونَ قد سَبَقَ منهُ ذِكْرُ الفَائِتَةِ أو لَمْ يَسْبِقْ منه لها ذكرٌ، نَصَّ عليهِ أحمدُ؛ لِعُمُومِ ما ذكرنَاهُ منَ الدَّليِل، واللهُ أَعلَمُ.
٢٠١ - مسألة؛ قال: ([فَإِنْ خشِىَ فَوَاتَ] (١) الوَقْتِ اعْتَقَدَ وَهُوَ فِيهَا أنْ لَا يُعِيدَهَا، وقَدْ أجْزَأَتْهُ، [ويَقْضِي الَّتِى عَلَيْهِ] (٢))
يَعْنِى إذا خَشِىَ فواتَ الوقتِ، قبلَ قَضَاءِ الفائِتَةِ، وإعادَةِ التي هو فيها، سَقَطَ
(٢٦) سقط من: م.(٢٧) في م: "أن صلاته صحيحة".(٢٨) في م: "بحديث أبي جمعة وبالقياس على المجموعتين".(٢٩) تقدم في صفحة ١٤٦ من الجزء الأول.(٣٠) في م: "قائما لم يعذر بالنسيان؛ لأن عليهما إمارة، وهو اجتماع الجماعة، بخلاف مسألتنا".(١) في م: "ومن خشى خروج".(٢) سقط من: م.